Practical Teaching Tip: Grading Rubrics

I know there are many schools of thought when it comes to assessment. However, for me I have found that utilizing detailed rubrics have been most productive in a high school setting.

Reasons detailed grading rubrics works:

• Students have a clear understanding of what I am looking for when I grade their projects
• Students are able to complete mid-project checks or formative assessments based on what they need to change or work on before they turn the project in
• Students can use the rubric to grade one another
• Parents have a clear understanding of how I am accessing their student's artwork
• My opinion about whether I think the art is "good" does not come into play
• It is very easy and fast to grade a project when all you have to do is check off boxes
• When I grade projects I do it during class through a critique so the students know what their grade is right away

Here are some examples of the way I set up different rubrics. The first section to the left is the criteria to which I am grading the project. The columns to the right is the amount of points awarded.

Sample Glaze Rubric

 (my ceramic projects get graded once for the project before it goes into the kiln and then again after it has been glaze fired)

3D: Glaze Rubric                                  
 Project Title:                                                                      

Name:                                                                                                                Class Period:                                            Grade:        /35

1.        Sketch a diagram of your piece on the back, color it with colored pencil and label the names of the glazes.

2.        What color scheme or variation of one did you choose? Circle: Primary, Secondary, Warm, Cool, Neutral, Complimentary, Analogous other:                                                                                

3.        What glazing technique did you use? Circle: Stencils, sgraffito, staining, under glaze, wax resist, layering, glass or mixing

Criteria	Weak (1)	Poor (2)	Average (3)	Good (4)	Excellent (5)
Color Scheme: Choose one of the following above or a variation. Overall the colors go well together.
2+ Coats: Student used 2 coats (or more depending on what the label stated) of glaze on entire piece.
Wax on Bottom: Student sealed bottom signature with wax. Glaze that accidentally got on the wax should be wiped away with a wet sponge.
Technique: Student included one of the techniques listed above
Bisque Ware was Properly Cleaned: Student washed piece before it was glazed, there is no crawl.
All areas are painted neatly: There is no bare clay body showing, all areas are cleanly painted.
Completed Questions Above	1	-	2	-	3

How do you grade art? I would love to hear NEW ideas :)

Happy Friday Art Lovers! Take time this weekend to make some art for yourself even if its just a drawing in a sketchbook.